• Consequence
  • Music
  • Film
  • TV
  • Heavy
Menu Consequence
Menu Shop Search Newsletter
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Features
  • Live
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Cover Story
Advertisement
  • Reviews
  • Film Reviews

Film Review: Indignation

A tale of youth, piety, and rage in Ohio circa 1955

B

Directed by

  • James Schamus

Starring

  • Logan Lerman
  • Sarah Gadon
  • Tracy Letts

Release Year

  • 2016
Dominick Suzanne-Mayer
July 25, 2016 | 2:00pm ET

    The following review was originally published as part of our Sundance Film Festival 2016 coverage.

    Indignation concerns itself with a number of quintessentially Philip Roth topics: Judaism, sexual repression, older forms of Americana, atheism. All of these are filtered through the story of Marcus Messner (Logan Lerman), a young college student in 1955 America who discovers firsthand, the hard way, just how difficult it was to assert one’s individuality in virtually any way in the post-WWII/Korean War era. He leaves his family’s butcher shop in New Jersey to attend Winesburg College, a prestigious and (crucially) Catholic institution in central Ohio, where he aspires to study law while keeping his head down and declaring as few affiliations as possible with anybody around him. Especially the Jewish fraternity that his father aggressively insists he join.

    Marcus is the kind of young man who cares little for the assigned restrictions of a dominant mainstream society, which in this case was one waging war against everything from draft dodgers to the sexually promiscuous to the dreaded “socialists.” James Schamus, in his directorial debut, frames Indignation’s vision of America as a place where the only options were assimilation, quiet repression, or an early death perceived by many as just. It’s a rather blunt-faced way of approaching the era, but it’s nevertheless passionate in its fervor, and it’s that passion that elevates Indignation above its occasional histrionics to moments of truly inspired drama.

    Related Video

    Once arrived, Marcus is forced to discover just how different he is and how little of the world he truly knows. These lessons chiefly come from two diametrically opposed sources. On one end, there’s Olivia Hutton (Sarah Gadon, who appears to have been plucked right from the film’s era). Olivia is everything Marcus is ill-equipped to deal with: furiously intelligent, sexually experienced, and struggling to deal with her own demons. On the other is Dean Caudwell (Tracy Letts), who delivers many of the campus’ required chapel addresses and is struck with curiosity about why Marcus feels himself such an ill fit for his assigned fellow Jewish roommates, especially if (as Marcus insists) he’s a reasonable type willing to compromise with his fellow students.

    Advertisement

    Compromise, in all its forms, is central to Indignation. Schamus, who also adapted Roth’s novel, finds one dramatic irony after the next in the many compromises Marcus has to make, to say nothing of those that Olivia already has long before the film picks up with their stories. Most exhilarating is the film’s central setpiece, which doubles as a thesis statement, in the form of a lengthy dialogue between Marcus and Caudwell when Marcus requests a room change and is accordingly required to speak with the Dean about why. Over nearly 20 minutes, Schamus simply lingers on a conversation, as Dean Caudwell wears Marcus down to honest answers about his contempt for the chapel requirement on moral grounds, and Marcus works himself into a fit of escalating apoplexy over the Dean’s unflappable manner. It’s a superb bit of performance, particularly on Lerman’s part, as he more than holds his own with Letts, who takes clear pleasure in sinking his teeth into such rich material. And it’s a distilled version of Indignation’s larger ideals; for Marcus there is no equivocation when it comes to his beliefs, not when it’s demanded of him and not even when some hills might not be particularly worth dying upon.

    It’s the central trio of performances that benefit Indignation most when the adaptation finds itself on shakier ground. While the film retains the novel’s time-jumping maneuvers and unreliable narration, Indignation sometimes feels as though it’s missing long chunks of necessary story. Character motivations shift incongruously in single scenes, and the sequences involving Olivia and Marcus that bookend the story feel especially digressive, as though the film is chasing a grander statement about the nature of fateful tragedy without being bothered to show the work beforehand. This same feeling of sudden progression extends to a late conversation between Marcus and his mother, in which Marcus is asked to make a terrible decision for scurrilous reasons, solely for her benefit even as she thinks it for his. The scene aims for tragic impact, and instead plays as forced.

    And yet, Indignation resonates with the tension of things said and unsaid, regretted and forgotten. Everybody within its universe has their reservations and their scapegoats, and in general, a thick fog of wartime paranoia hangs heavy over the film’s seemingly innocuous events. Marcus’ mother insists that “weak people are not harmless,” and this notion of weakness and moral frailty as the worst sin that can be committed makes it fairly easy to see why Marcus can barely contain himself within this world or why Olivia seeks so many different means of escaping it. Indignation recalls a crueler time in history, in a manner that offers a strong reminder that melodrama, when executed so well and acted to the nines as this is, isn’t always a profanity as it’s so often treated. Sometimes the most amplified emotions are the only ones that can speak to a world in such turmoil.

    Advertisement
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Reddit

More on this topic

  • James Schamus
  • Logan Lerman
  • Philip Roth
  • Sarah Gadon
  • Sundance 2016 Coverage
  • Tracy Letts

Sign up for updates

Subscribe to our email digest and get the latest breaking news in music, film, and television, tour updates, access to exclusive giveaways, and more straight to your inbox.

Advertisement

Popular Stories

Latest Stories

A-
werewolf by night review marvel disney plus special presentation halloween special

Werewolf by Night Is a Marvelous Monster Mash: Review

October 6, 2022

B
Hellraiser Review Jamie Clayton Hulu

Hellraiser Review: A True Reboot That's Pretty Darned Good

October 5, 2022

C+
david o russell amsterdam film first look release date

Not Even An All-Star Cast Can Save David O. Russell's Amsterdam: Review

October 4, 2022

B+
White Noise Review

NYFF Review: Noah Baumbach Delightfully Skewers Our Fear of Death in White Noise

October 3, 2022

B+
Till Review Danielle Deadwyler

Till Digs Into a Deeply Shameful, Deeply American Tragedy: Review

October 1, 2022

B-
Master Gardener Review Paul Schrader

Paul Schrader's Master Gardener Treads Very Familiar Soil: Review

October 1, 2022

A-
Decision to Leave Review

Chan-wook Park's Decision to Leave Is a Sizzling Romantic Thriller: Review

September 30, 2022

D+
Greatest Beer Run Ever Review

The Greatest Beer Run Ever Is a Pretty Likeable Movie, and That's a Huge Problem: Review

September 30, 2022

Advertisement

News

  • Music
  • New Music
  • Album Streams
  • Upcoming Releases
  • Tours
  • Film
  • TV
  • Pop Culture

Reviews

  • Music Reviews
  • Film Reviews
  • TV Reviews
  • Concert Reviews
  • Festival Reviews

Features

  • Editorials
  • Interviews
  • Cover Stories
  • Lists
  • Guides
  • CoSign
  • Song of the Week

Live

  • Tickets
  • Festival News
  • Tour Dates
  • Photo Galleries
  • Music Instruments & Gear

Heavy

  • News
  • Interviews
  • Concerts

More

  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Wellness
  • Giveaways

Other sites

  • Heavy Consequence
  • Consequence Media
  • Modern Drummer
  • About
  • Privacy policy
  • Advertising
  • Work For Us
  • Terms
  • Contact
  • Copyright
  • Do Not Sell My Personal Information

Download our app

  • Get it on the App Store
  • Get it on Google Play
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitch
  • Tiktok
Consequence
Current story

Film Review: Indignation

Menu Shop Search Newsletter
Consequence
News
  • News
  • Music
  • New Music
  • Album Streams
  • Upcoming Releases
  • Tours
  • Film
  • TV
  • Pop Culture
Reviews
  • Music Reviews
  • Film Reviews
  • TV Reviews
  • Concert Reviews
  • Festival Reviews
Features
  • All Features
  • Editorials
  • Interviews
  • Cover Stories
  • Lists
  • Guides
  • CoSign
  • Song of the Week
Live
  • Tickets
  • Festival News
  • Tour Dates
  • Photo Galleries
  • Music Instruments & Gear
Podcasts
  • The Opus
  • Kyle Meredith With...
  • Stanning BTS
  • The Story Behind the Song
  • The What
  • Going There with Dr. Mike
  • The Rome and Duddy Show
Videos
  • Interviews
  • Two for the Road
  • First Time I Heard
  • When I Made
  • Battle of the Bandmates
  • Peer 2 Peer
  • Essays
  • Fan Theories
Heavy
  • News
  • Interviews
  • Concerts
  • Premieres
  • Culture
  • Beyond the Boys Club
  • Mining Metal
Shop
  • Shop
  • Giveaways
Hometowns

Follow Consequence

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitch
  • Tiktok
Close
Close