• Consequence
  • Music
  • Film
  • TV
  • Heavy
Menu Consequence
Menu Shop Search Newsletter
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Features
  • Live
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Contest
Advertisement
  • Reviews
  • Film Reviews

Film Review: Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

Gareth Edwards' sobering meditation on war is not without its own distractions

C+

Directed by

  • Gareth Edwards

Starring

  • Felicity Jones
  • Diego Luna
  • Mads Mikkelsen
  • Donnie Yen
  • Forest Whitaker

Release Year

  • 2016
Michael Roffman
December 13, 2016 | 12:00pm ET

    “Rebellions are built on hope.”

    At least that’s what Cassian Andor (Diego Luna) tells Jyn Erso (Felicity Jones) early on in Rogue One: A Star Wars Story. The two are butting heads with one another over their respective lots in life: he’s the Rebel Alliance’s trusty Intelligence officer while she’s the estranged daughter of the guy who designed the Death Star. Naturally, that latter attribute hasn’t afforded Erso much of an existence for herself, at least not one with the “luxury of political opinions,” but she’s starting to come around. In fact, everyone’s starting to come around in Gareth Edwards’ intergalactic war drama.

    Make no mistake, Rogue One isn’t your average Star Wars adventure, and that’s sort of the point. Disney’s first anthology film — which, in this case, is more or less a clever way of ignoring the “prequel” designation — attempts to be a brazen, gritty outlook on their blockbuster galaxy from far, far away. There are stakes. There are consequences. There is death. Unlike last year’s punchy The Force Awakens, this is a dark and sobering meditation on the collateral damage and sacrifices that happen offscreen while we’re busy cheering on Jedis and laughing it up like a bunch of fuzzballs.

    (Ranking: Every Star Wars Film and TV Show From Worst to Best)

    Edwards has a penchant for this stuff, though. His 2014 reboot of Godzilla thrived with all sorts of war-torn carnage, and despite reports of lengthy re-shoots involving Tony Gilroy this past summer, Edwards’ treacherous magic remains intact. His attention to scope when it comes to battle is hands down the strongest facet of Rogue One. The way he gracefully pans from gutsy hand-to-hand combat and up to the skies for sprawling aerial battles is like watching a better version of last year’s Battlefront. The final act on the tropical planet of Scarif is worth the price of admission alone.

    Advertisement
    Related Video

    Of course, darkness can only go so far when it comes to Star Wars, and while this is arguably the most unforgiving chapter in the franchise, it’s still riddled with lighter popcorn fare that keeps things bubbly and friendly: Alan Tudyk delivers some yuks by voicing sassy Imperial-turned-Rebel droid K-2SO; Donnie Yen charms with his words of wisdom as the blind, Force-obsessed warrior Chirrut Îmwe; and a rogues gallery of familiar faces pop up in all the right and wrong places — from big baddies like Darth Vader and Grand Moff Tarkin to heroic leaders like Mon Mothma and Bail Organa.

    That last part becomes rather distracting and winds up fracturing much of Rogue One. Reason being, the core story — ahem, Rebel spies stealing secret plans to the Empire’s unholy Death Star — has to keep accommodating these random cameos and Easter eggs, to the point that they actually take minutes away from more serviceable areas like, you know, character development. As such, it’s not surprising that the whole Rogue One team lacks some much-needed chemistry or why Ben Mendelsohn’s Orson Krennic feels less like a villain and more like a forced plot device.

    A few of these discrepancies may be due to those aforementioned reshoots. When they were first acknowledged by The Hollywood Reporter, it was rumored that the goal was to “lighten the mood, bring some levity into the story, and restore a sense of fun to the adventure,” all of which was (obviously) denied by the studio. Now, after seeing the film, it’s clear that something happened over the summer. Not only is it plagued by glaring tonal issues, but there are a number of not-so-subtle story gaps that scream of missing key scenes. At times, it feels like the action’s going from point A to point D.

    (Read: A Brief History of Star Wars Gaming)

    Advertisement

    Regardless, Rogue One still suffers from a terrible case of prequelitis. After all, we know where this story leads to: A young Carrie Fisher sends two droids packing, gets kidnapped by James Earl Jones, only to be saved by a couple hunks (and a wookie) who blast the multi-octillion dollar piece of hardware into smithereens. There’s fanfare, more sequels, rinse and repeat. So, what’s the point to this? Good question. Whereas last year’s The Force Awakens felt refreshing for finally looking forward after years of meandering, uninspiring prequels, Rogue One feels like a step back … and that’s not good.

    Even worse, the film indulges in the kind of extravagance that made those prequels so annoying, specifically the way it’s beholden to the source material. When Rogue One was first announced, there was hope — there’s that word again — that this would be something totally separate, totally unique, and totally removed from the initial series. That’s just not the case here: For Christ’s sake, there’s a spooky CGI reimagining of Peter Cushing as Tarkin, and it’s hardly just a quick cameo. No, this is a walking and talking role that does nothing but remind you of the other films again and again. It’s really limiting.

    Advertisement

    And those limitations act in direct opposition to the actual story at hand, not to mention its widely eclectic A-list cast of Jones, Luna, Mendelsohn, Tudyk, Yen, Jiang Wen, Forest Whitaker, Mads Mikkelsen, and Riz Ahmed. Never has this franchise brandished such a diverse ensemble, and although they’re each singularly cool enough to warrant individual action figures, they’re often straddled with expository dialogue straight out of Wookiepedia. Again, it’s because this film has to work towards a specific finish line with specific expectations and specific demands, and that requires specific storytelling.

    You know what that sounds like? The Marvel Cinematic Universe.

    Granted, Disney’s other hot commodity has been selling like hotcakes for over half a decade, so it makes sense that they’d try to weld that success to Star Wars. The problem is that by subscribing to that formula, they’re forfeiting their ability to make these spin-offs and anthology films branch out into all kinds of directions and genres, which is something Lucasfilm president Kathleen Kennedy initially wanted to do. Because if we’re to observe Marvel’s catalogue of films, it’s very rare that any of them — outside of, say, Guardians of the Galaxy — strays too far stylistically and even structurally from the core.

    (Check Out: A Padawan’s Porn Guide to Star Wars)

    To its credit, Rogue One does an admirable job at trying new things, at least visually. Fans who complained about seeing the same type of planets in The Force Awakens should find solace in the rich scenery to this story, whether it’s the Blomkamp-esque filth of Jedha’s city streets or the Beach Boys bliss of Scarif’s sunny confines. For the first time in a long while, you’re actually transported to worlds that don’t feel all that familiar — because let’s be honest, Jakku was basically Tattooine with more scrap metal — and there’s something pretty magical about that notion. It’s what every Star Wars film should do.

    Advertisement

    What’s ultimately frustrating about Rogue One is how it’s clearly coming from two minds. There’s Edwards’ impressionistic views of war, lensed to melancholic heaven by cinematographer Greig Fraser, with wide establishing shots that dazzle for its achingly brusque naturalism. And then on top of all that, there’s the more standard Star Wars fluff, from Michael Giacchino’s bouncy flourishes of John Williams (not exactly the grand departure Alexandre Desplat might have been) to the redundant droid humor involving mathematical odds (at least six references to that joke). For a film that’s all about hope and rebellion, it’s kind of ironic how it’s such a conflicted mess in and of itself.

    The Force should have been stronger with this one.

    Trailer: 

  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Reddit
Advertisement

Actors

  • Michael Giacchino

More on this topic

  • Alan Tudyk
  • Anthology
  • Ben Mendelsohn
  • Chris Weitz
  • Diego Luna
  • Donnie Yen
  • Felicity Jones
  • Forest Whitaker
  • Gareth Edwards
  • James Earl Jones
  • Jiang Wen
  • Mads Mikkelsen
  • Rogue One: A Star Wars Story
  • Sequel
  • Spin-off
  • Star Wars
  • Tony Gilroy

Sign up for updates

Subscribe to our email digest and get the latest breaking news in music, film, and television, tour updates, access to exclusive giveaways, and more straight to your inbox.

Advertisement

Popular Stories

Latest Stories

A-
werewolf by night review marvel disney plus special presentation halloween special

Werewolf by Night Is a Marvelous Monster Mash: Review

October 6, 2022

B
Hellraiser Review Jamie Clayton Hulu

Hellraiser Review: A True Reboot That's Pretty Darned Good

October 5, 2022

C+
david o russell amsterdam film first look release date

Not Even An All-Star Cast Can Save David O. Russell's Amsterdam: Review

October 4, 2022

B+
White Noise Review

NYFF Review: Noah Baumbach Delightfully Skewers Our Fear of Death in White Noise

October 3, 2022

B+
Till Review Danielle Deadwyler

Till Digs Into a Deeply Shameful, Deeply American Tragedy: Review

October 1, 2022

B-
Master Gardener Review Paul Schrader

Paul Schrader's Master Gardener Treads Very Familiar Soil: Review

October 1, 2022

A-
Decision to Leave Review

Chan-wook Park's Decision to Leave Is a Sizzling Romantic Thriller: Review

September 30, 2022

D+
Greatest Beer Run Ever Review

The Greatest Beer Run Ever Is a Pretty Likeable Movie, and That's a Huge Problem: Review

September 30, 2022

Advertisement

News

  • Music
  • New Music
  • Album Streams
  • Upcoming Releases
  • Tours
  • Film
  • TV
  • Pop Culture

Reviews

  • Music Reviews
  • Film Reviews
  • TV Reviews
  • Concert Reviews
  • Festival Reviews

Features

  • Editorials
  • Interviews
  • Cover Stories
  • Lists
  • Guides
  • CoSign
  • Song of the Week

Live

  • Tickets
  • Festival News
  • Tour Dates
  • Photo Galleries
  • Music Instruments & Gear

Heavy

  • News
  • Interviews
  • Concerts

More

  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Wellness
  • Giveaways

Other sites

  • Heavy Consequence
  • Consequence Media
  • Modern Drummer
  • About
  • Privacy policy
  • Advertising
  • Work For Us
  • Terms
  • Contact
  • Copyright
  • Do Not Sell My Personal Information

Download our app

  • Get it on the App Store
  • Get it on Google Play
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitch
  • Tiktok
Consequence
Current story

Film Review: Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

Menu Shop Search Newsletter
Consequence
News
  • News
  • Music
  • New Music
  • Album Streams
  • Upcoming Releases
  • Tours
  • Film
  • TV
  • Pop Culture
Reviews
  • Music Reviews
  • Film Reviews
  • TV Reviews
  • Concert Reviews
  • Festival Reviews
Features
  • All Features
  • Editorials
  • Interviews
  • Cover Stories
  • Lists
  • Guides
  • CoSign
  • Song of the Week
Live
  • Tickets
  • Festival News
  • Tour Dates
  • Photo Galleries
  • Music Instruments & Gear
Podcasts
  • The Opus
  • Kyle Meredith With...
  • Stanning BTS
  • The Story Behind the Song
  • The What
  • Going There with Dr. Mike
  • The Rome and Duddy Show
Videos
  • Interviews
  • Two for the Road
  • First Time I Heard
  • When I Made
  • Battle of the Bandmates
  • Peer 2 Peer
  • Essays
  • Fan Theories
Heavy
  • News
  • Interviews
  • Concerts
  • Premieres
  • Culture
  • Beyond the Boys Club
  • Mining Metal
Shop
  • Shop
  • Giveaways

Follow Consequence

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitch
  • Tiktok
Close
Close